"I’m an easy mark for books like Ahab’s Rolling Sea: A Natural History of ‘Moby-Dick,’ which I’ve read a perhaps unhealthy number of times, in light of Annie Dillard’s opinion that Melville’s baggy masterpiece is the ‘best book ever written about nature.’ Focusing on nineteenth century oceanography, natural history, and, of course, the whalers’ understanding of his prey’s remarkable intelligence, King’s book is a fascinating and rare thing: a vital addition to Melville studies."
— Stephen Sparks
“King uses modern sources and historical texts to take a fresh look at Melville’s book—published in the same decade as Charles Darwin’s On the Origin of Species—with the well-defined brief of assessing its natural history content. The result is a lighthearted and incredibly enjoyable read that manages somehow, at the right moments, to be both broad and narrow in scope. It should be required reading for anyone attempting Moby-Dick. . . . No captive of the library, King is an experienced seaman and an open-minded and intrepid guide. A visiting associate professor of maritime literature and history at the Sea Education Association in Woods Hole, Massachusetts, he is willing to pull on his old Sou’wester and sail into the watery part of the world. . . . King writes ably and in scholarly detail about albatrosses, ambergris, baleen, barnacles, seals, sharks, sperm whale behavior and language, swordfish, typhoons, and all sorts of marine and cetological marginalia. . . . [A] talented and clear-eyed . . . writer.”
— Christopher J. Kemp
“A treasure trove. King situates Melville as a person of his time, writing amid a quickening pace of discoveries about the natural world but, pre-On the Origin of Species, inclined to couch them as further disclosures of God’s design.”
— Stephen Phillips
“Ahab’s Rolling Sea highlights our destructiveness as it teases fact from fiction in Moby-Dick, the obsessive hunt for a great white whale. . . . Rigorous. . . . Original.”
— Chris Simms
“King gives us natural history done Melville-style, looking over a ship’s rail, and this ingenious focus neatly weds field science and literary history, yielding a study that is fresh, provocative, and welcome.”
— William Howarth
"Ultimately, answering these questions involves poetry more than science. Melville has combined the rational, objective, Darwinian perspective with the emotional, poetic, Emersonian perspective, pushing the reader to see nature as both dangerous and damaged. Here is King’s main point: that Melville’s novel can now be read as an introduction to environmental issues of the twenty-first century."
— John P. Loonam
"Herman Melville’s sprawling masterpiece Moby-Dick is a fictional feat studded with empirical evidence, reveals maritime historian King in this invigorating study. King traces references to ethology, meteorology, marine microbiota and the oceans to Melville’s sailing experience in the Pacific and wranglings with the works of scientists William Scoresby, Louis Agassiz and others. Moby-Dick, King boldly avers, is a 'proto-Darwinian fable'—and its beleaguered narrator, Ishmael, an early environmentalist."
"This examination of Moby-Dick as nature writing could be a sneaky way to get the English majors on your shopping list to read about science."
— American Scientist
"King reflects on what we have learned and lost from the oceans since Melville's time. He answers questions many readers surely ponder. . . . Naturally, the book is full of spoilers. Read Moby-Dick, read this, then read Moby-Dick again."
— BBC Wildlife
“A rather schematic structure—Ahab’s Rolling Sea could be used as a reference book, a zoological concordance to Moby-Dick—is combined with a genuinely gripping retelling of the tale.”
— Brian Morton
“Are you? a Moby-Dickhead? If so, are you enough of a Moby-Dickhead to have visited the Phallological Museum in Iceland to inspect a sperm whale’s penis? This is one of the many intrepid expeditions undertaken by King in the course of researching Ahab’s Rolling Sea. His book, like Moby-Dick itself, tells you everything you ever wanted to know about whales but were too ashamed to ask. The fact that the sperm whale’s penis, or ‘grandissimus’, is four and a half feet long is just one of its juicier details. . . . It turns out that, with due allowance for the state of knowledge in the 1850s, Melville got a surprising amount right about whales: their size, their bone structure, their mass, even their emotional lives. . . . Anyone who isn’t completely turned off by sea creatures will enjoy surfing the waves of information that roll genially from this book. Ahab’s Rolling Sea also has a big thesis. King argues that Moby-Dick offers a ‘proto-Darwinian decentring of the human and the elevation of the whale.’ . . . It would be hard to fault either the motives or the facts underlying King’s ecological zeal.”
— London Review of Books
"King, a visiting associate professor of maritime literature and history (what a fascinating title this is!), runs after the Leviathan of literary semantics in the most imaginative way: testing what Melville and people of his era knew about their natural environment, maritime ecosystems, birds, cetaceans, and whales before he published Moby-Dick in 1851. . . . King does his best not to be another Ahab seeing his 'White Whale' escaping. And he actually makes it: from the detailed research of the marine fauna to the possible influences of Emerson, Thoreau, Darwin, Bowditch on Melville. This is the retelling of Moby-Dick from an imaginative point of view: from the Pequod towards the cosmos surrounding us in the era of new environmentalism."
— Dimitris Doulgeridis
“An exquisitely detailed and gorgeously written book that reminds us of the wonder of Melville's novel and of the natural world in which it takes place. Fascinating accounts and descriptions of whales, swordfish, sharks, giant squid, ambergris, etc., and of the sea itself: then and now. And informed by a writer who has spent years at sea, is now a professor of maritime literature and history at the Sea Education Association in Woods Hole, Massachusetts. King gives an original, loving rereading of Melville's novel. He is himself a master storyteller whose handsomely illustrated book is deeply informed and full of delightful surprises."
— Jay Neugeboren
"Depending on who you are, reading Moby-Dick, first published in 1851, could be a sleep-inducing slog or a stellar sea yarn of man versus whale. But the book has (sea) legs, and since its release has proved to be one of the most enduring books of American fiction. Its literary merits have been discussed and debated, but King, a professor of maritime literature and history, examines the book as a work of nature writing . . . He does extensive reporting, delving into everything from the rigging of whaleships to the diet of sperm whales."
— Hakai Magazine
"A unique take on Melville...The book is unquestionably well researched: King blends library research with personal experience and draws on interviews with contemporary 'oceanic' professionals, including maritime-historian colleagues, ocean scientists, and sailors. He also provides scores of photographs and other pertinent illustrations. Anyone interested in Melville will find this rich and insightful study fascinating—but those readers curious enough to see Moby-Dick as an oceanographic encyclopedia will benefit most."
— J. W. Miller, Gonzaga University
“King dissects the language and information available to Melville, including books found within Melville’s library, and identifies how edited versions of what was understood at the time were twisted to serve the story. The reader comes to appreciate Melville’s thorough natural history research, especially in light of the fact that Moby-Dick was written at a time when it was not yet decided whether whales were fish or mammals, and when scientific knowledge was shoehorned into a religious worldview...I thoroughly enjoyed King’s well-researched analysis of the classic tale which ‘offers a benchmark for how Americans understood the ocean in the mid-nineteenth century’ and in doing so, compares and contrasts this with our perceptions of the ocean today.”
— The Niche
"Employing Melville’s maritime setting as a base camp for this ambitious excursion into our present-day relationship with the ocean and its denizens, Ahab’s Rolling Sea is that rarest of scholarly books: one that delights as it informs. . . . Key to the book’s success is King’s skill as a writer. He weaves impressive research—much of it archival—with his own insightful and enthusiastic prose. Topping it off, the book is filled with a rich assemblage of illustrations, maps, and photographs. King writes, 'Like the industry of whaling itself, Melville reveled in the chance to show how the ugly, dirty deep revealed both man’s hypocrisies and nature’s treasures.' The same can be said of Ahab’s Rolling Sea, a book that, like Melville’s novel and like the wonders of the ocean, manages to thrill, to educate, and to inspire."
— Matthew Wynn Sivils
“Tired of binge-watching those mind-numbing programs and movies? During this pandemic, we’ve been warned to exercise regularly and that includes our brain. With extra time for nonessential activities, it’s an opportunity to read a few good books—especially venturing into unfamiliar territory. . . . This book is excellent. Even if you haven’t read Melville’s classic of sea literature, you will be amazed at his command of the environmental world that is its setting. . . . What King says will entertain, inform, amuse and sadden you."
— JoAnne Fuerst
"Simply breathtaking, in that it takes one’s breath away and refills the lungs with a gust of salty sea breeze...Ahab’s Rolling Sea collects accounts from literary criticism, theory, climate activism, and natural history for a deep dive into one of the most popular maritime novels around—Herman Melville’s Moby-Dick...The relatability and readability of Ahab’s Rolling Sea, at a time when the sea has much receded from daily life, is a testament to King’s pedagogical, sailorly, and descriptive mastery. King invites us to stand aloft with him and Ishmael, and look out toward the wonderful, ever-rolling sea. Maybe, if we look close enough, we will even get to see a whale.”
— Alison Maas
"King’s book ballasts one’s appreciation for Melville’s vision with rich freights of lore, observation, scientific data, and history of ideas. It is an admirable companion to the novel and the mind bold enough to bring it into the world."
— The Nautilus
"The chance that someone could write something new and fresh about such a book seems as unlikely as a big haul from our over-fished oceans, yet King achieves this. . . He has produced a powerful ecocritical analysis of Moby-Dick, reinforcing the novel as essential reading for all who sail, paddle, wander or simply ponder on the sea."
— Mandy Haggith, Inverness College, University of the Highlands and Islands
“Anyone who loves Moby-Dick should read this book.”
— Nathaniel Philbrick, author of the National Book Award–winning "In the Heart of the Sea: The Tragedy of the Whaleship Essex" and "Why Read 'Moby-Dick'?"
“It took me decades to appreciate that Melville’s messy, uncontainable, surging Moby-Dick is perhaps the greatest book ever written about the sea, and about the human relationship with the living world, and perhaps the only book sufficiently un-jaded by mercantilism and modernity to be worthy of the actual ocean itself in all its raw, uncontrollable, surging majesty. But if you don’t want to wait decades for Melville’s magnificence to be revealed, you can cheat and read King’s book. Ahab’s Rolling Sea is a marvelous guide to the magic and mystery that was Melville’s gift to us, for King reveals the deep, deep backstory of the making of Moby-Dick, the vast pots of experience and information that Melville simmered down, and even the missing ingredients of his age, that made Moby-Dick the richest bouillabaisse in all of literature. Oh, and about Melville’s missing ingredients—they’re here, in King’s terrific book.”
— Carl Safina, author of "Song for the Blue Ocean: Encounters Along the World's Coasts and Beneath the Seas" and "Becoming Wild: How Animal Cultures Raise Families, Create Beauty, and Achieve Peace"
“Ahab’s Rolling Sea is a wide-ranging, highly personal, richly eclectic, and extremely well-researched book whose style and humor, combined with its rigor, suggest the potential for popularity even beyond the fascinations of this self-confessed whalehead. Who could not warm to a chapter titled ‘Gulls, Sea-Ravens, and Albatrosses’ or ‘Sword-Fish and Lively Grounds,’ or be intrigued by ‘Phosphorescence’? There’s a Melvillean romance here, and it sits especially well with King’s love and empathy for human as well as natural history. A contemporary, witty, almost postmodern field guide.”
— Philip Hoare, author of "RISINGTIDEFALLINGSTAR," "The Sea Inside," "The Whale," and "Leviathan"
“King decisively settles any lingering questions about Moby-Dick, nineteenth-century whales and whaling, and all lore and literature of the sea. More than establishing a factual basis for Ishmael’s fiction-making, King writes passionately on climate change, economic pressures on sea creatures, and the future Melville confronts in his marvelous encounter with the ‘wonder-world’ of whaling. King’s deep knowledge grounds lively storytelling, keen observations drawn from years of sailing, and an eye for details that will make Melville’s book come alive. But even if you haven’t read Moby-Dick, you will revel in this storehouse of fascinating tales and arcana, from Ambergris to Zeuglodon. A treasure for library, classroom, or bedside table.”
— Wyn Kelley, Massachusetts Institute of Technology, author of "Melville's City: Literary and Urban Form in Nineteenth-Century New York" and "Herman Melville: An Introduction"
“This is a superb work of popular scholarship that rivals the best books of maritime nonfiction currently in print. For any teacher, reader, or aficionado of Melville’s magnum opus the present work will be a joy to read; for anyone curious about the current state of the marine environment, this book will be eye-opening.”
— Dan Brayton, Middlebury College, author of “Shakespeare’s Ocean: An Ecocritical Exploration”